Metal Fabrication Design Practices That Reduce Scrap

Tag Archive: metal stamping design

  1. Metal Fabrication Design Practices That Reduce Scrap

    Comments Off on Metal Fabrication Design Practices That Reduce Scrap

    More manufacturers are focusing on reducing scrap from production — not only is it beneficial to the environment and to the manufacturer’s bottom line, but customers also see a reduction in cost and turnaround time.


    Rather than selling a lot of excess scrap to a scrap dealer — which only generates about 5% of a manufacturer’s original material cost, plus additional handling and transporting costs — manufacturers like ESI are instead concentrating on minimizing the amount of scrap produced in the first place. Those savings are then passed onto customers to save them time and resources.

    In this article, we’ll discuss three metal stamping design and production practices that reduce scrap: nesting practices, repurposing scrap for parts, and identifying production techniques that use less material scrap.

    Leverage Nesting Practices

    Design engineers can leverage nesting practices to get the most out of each sheet of material. “Nesting” refers to setting smaller parts of the same thickness inside larger parts within a sheet so that both parts are created in subsequent tool strokes. This generates both cost and time savings by reducing total tooling costs and eliminating the need for a second press and operator. progressive-die-stamping-part

    When planning out nesting operations, ensure the following:

    • — The production volume for the larger of the two parts is greater
    • — Production speeds are the same for all parts
    • — The sheet material’s grain direction is not parallel to the bending direction — this can result in cracking

    In one example of stamping a small part from within a larger part, ESI was asked to handle production of 20,000 D-rings per year for a scuba diving equipment brand. Our engineers examined the challenge and realized we could stamp an additional smaller ring if we utilized the material from the inside of the larger “D” cut, enabling us to stamp two parts for the price of one.

    Using our progressive die tooling techniques, we were able to create stainless steel rings in multiple sizes using scrap, significantly reducing process waste. Ultimately, our design saved the client money on materials and improved production speeds.

    Repurpose Scrap to Produce Parts

    While nesting will not completely eliminate scrap, there are options available before sending scrap to a dealer.  It is common practice for stamping shops to use offal dies — also known as recovery dies — to produce other parts by loading the scrap into a line die.

    Scrap may also be fastened or otherwise combined to produce a continuous strip that is fed into a progressive die. However, it is important to avoid strained or work-hardened material and to note that scrap metal can lose some of its ductility and forming characteristics.

    Consider Different Forming Methods

    Ultimately, you should always use the metal forming method that delivers the design you need at the highest quality. However, there are also designs that can be manufactured via multiple forming methods. For those, it’s worth looking into an alternative method that results in less scrap and other benefits, like higher quality or even faster turnaround.

    For example, ESI has found that some metal component designs our customers bring to us can actually be stamped instead of machined. During the design consultation, we’ll work with the customer to understand the part’s application and specifications, and will then make recommendations that deliver better results. If a part can be stamped instead of machined, it cuts turnaround time and costs significantly.

    Metal stamping also generates less material scrap than machining, and will result in a cheaper price per piece than machined parts — in part due to the reduction in scrap brought on by scrap-reducing practices such as nesting, described above.

    Looking for more design tips and best practices? ESI has you covered — our Metal Stamping Design Guide includes drawings and tips to avoid costly errors and design higher-quality components. Download it today for free!

    metal stamping design guide
    Download Free Guide

  2. Ask an Engineer: Metal Stamping Design

    Comments Off on Ask an Engineer: Metal Stamping Design

    Metal forming is a complex process that can include a number of tactics — blanking, punching, bending, and piercing, to name a few.


    When used effectively, these tactics allow manufacturers to produce high-quality and cost-effective metal components. However, a few factors play into this quality and efficiency, and each project varies in materials, design and complexity:

    • – How do you know whether your part’s design will work for the intended application?
    • – Will your material of choice withstand all the elements it needs to function?

    ESI brought in our Engineering Manager, Mack Hodges, to answer some of the most frequently asked questions we receive about the metal stamping process.


    Q: How do I keep costs low for a metal stamping project?

    A: Optimizing the cost of your metal stamping project involves careful consideration of three main factors: material selection, dimensional tolerances, and secondary or post-production processes.

    • Material

    Appropriate material selection is usually the first and most effective step to lowering costs. For a given application, consider whether an alternative metal with similar properties can be used. For example, when creating components for use in corrosive environments, another, more cost-effective metal with similar corrosion resistance could be considered.

    • Tolerances

    Achieving tight tolerances during manufacturing can be complex due to the sensitivity of the component’s dimensions. Tight tolerances often require additional tooling maintenance and downtime which adds to the part cost.  Revaluate your project and determine whether the tolerances need to be as tight as specified.

    • Secondary Processes

    Post-production processes – such as smoothing the edges of the stamped part – can also incur additional project costs. Vibratory deburring and edge grinding usually involve complex machinery and can be potentially expensive depending on the size of the component and its production volume. Evaluate whether less costly methods of edge smoothing, such as coining, can be used for your stamped metal parts.

    Q. How long does it take to build custom tooling?

    A: In general, custom tool building can range anywhere from 10 to 20 weeks. Design and construction of custom tooling typically involve several steps—from 3D CAD/CAM engineering and design, to EDM machining. These processes are highly dependent on the size and complexity of the tool design, the total number of stamping operations needed to produce the part, and the overall production volume.

    Q. What are some common defects that happen during metal stamping?

    A: Defects typically occur when proper procedures and best stamping practices are not followed. Some of the most common metal stamping defects are:

    • Improper Edge-to-Hole Spacing and Bulges

    The clearance between the edge of a hole and the edge of the part should be at least twice the material thickness.

    edge-to-hole spacing

    E = 2T

    E = edge distance
    T = part thickness

    If the edge-to-hole distance is less than this recommended value, bulging at the outer edge of the material can occur.

    • Deformed Holes

    If a part is bent too close to a hole, this can cause the shape of the hole to distort and become deformed. For holes less than 2.5 mm (0.1 in), the distance between the outer edge of the hole and the outer edge of the bend should be at least twice the material thickness plus the bend radius:

    deformed holes metal stamping

    D = 2T + R

    D = distance between edge of hole and bend
    T = material thickness
    R = bend radius

    For holes greater than 2.5 mm (0.1 in), this distance should be at least 2.5 times the material thickness plus the bend radius:

    D = 2.5T + R

    • Burrs at Stamped Edges

    When metal is cut, the downward stress caused by the weight of the material causes the metal to fracture – or “shear off” – when the cut nears the end of the metal. This results in a fracture angle known as a stamping burr.

    burrs at stamped edges

    While burrs are usually not problematic, they can cause dimensional issues in applications with tight tolerances. Burrs can be addressed by secondary processes such as vibratory deburring, grinding, and coining.

    • Bending Cracks

    Some high-strength metals possess lower amounts of ductility and plasticity when compared to lower-strength metals such as mild steel. They are, therefore, more brittle by comparison, and are not as easily bent into shape.

    bending cracks - metal stamping

    This makes some high-strength alloys prone to cracking when bent in a direction that is perpendicular to the grain direction. It is therefore essential that high-strength materials be oriented in such a way that bends are done parallel to the direction of the grain.

    Q. How do I find a company with faster lead times?

    A: Lead time for the production of a custom component is usually related to a company’s manufacturing capabilities and work load. The advent of newer metal stamping equipment and technologies have allowed manufacturers to produce high-quality parts at a faster rate. For example, multi-out tooling allows multiple components to be stamped simultaneously.

    We hope that some of your most important questions were addressed in this article. Should you have any further questions, our engineering team is more than happy to answer them for you. Feel free to contact us with your questions, and we will be sure to get back to you as soon as possible. Alternatively, you can also download our comprehensive Metal Stamping Design Guide.

    Download free Metal Stamping Design tips

Have any questions? Click Here X
Starting a project? Use our material selection tool X